The ultimate guide to Brooklyn’s free and cheap comedy shows

by -
9
Jon Hamm in an apple suit, among the surprises at Brooklyn’s free comedy shows. Photo via David Andrako.

If you’re like me you probably don’t have a job that provides healthcare, and since Obamacare has yet to actually take effect, the only sensible way to treat illness is with the medicinal powers of laughter. This huge roundup includes regular, hilarious Brooklyn (and a few Manhattan) comedy shows that provide hilarity for free, or at least on the cheap.

The shows featured here are distinctly not your average hit-or-miss, audience-heckling standup acts (partly because I can’t bring myself to sit through that stuff long enough to review it). Even as Brooklyn’s comedy scene has gotten larger and better, churning out the Kristen Schaals and other future stars of the world, the best comedy has remained budget-friendly. These are the kind of shows where you can see big names as well as the best up-and coming entertainment in the New York scene without having to break the bank. To paraphrase a Hannibal Burress quote, comedy shouldn’t be a luxury. It’s a necessity.

THE FREE SHOWS

BIG TERRIFIC
A weekly comedy show hosted by Max SilvestriGabe Liedman, and Bored to Death/SNL’s Jenny Slate  (she’s the one who famously dropped that f-bomb on air! Fun stuff!). [Slate moved to LA, but the show is still on!] The show is in its fourth year and these comedy veterans know what they’re doing. Lineups have been known to include both burgeoning local acts and internationally known acts.

When: Wednesdays, doors at 8pm, show at 8:30pm
Cost: FREE
WhereCameo Gallery, 93 North 6th Street, Williamsburg

DIVE COMEDY
Comedy, storytellers and music hosted by super funny ladies Giulia Rozzi and Brooke Van Poppelen. Great indie comics and people that have appeared on Late Night With Jimmy Falon, Comedy Central, LOUIE, the Late Late Show, Letterman, the Moth, Best Week Ever VH1, and the list goes on and on …. trust me on this one!

When: Second and fourth Mondays of Every Month, 9pm
Cost: FREE
WhereFreddy’s Back Room, 627 5th Ave. (between 18th St & 17th St), Park Slope

_____________________________

COMEDY AT THE KNITTING FACTORY, HOSTED BY HANNIBAL BURESS
Proof that big names in comedy don’t have to cost a dime; any given Sunday you can find former SNL and 30 Rock writer Hannibal Buress regaling the crowd with his famously cool comedic timing. This show is always packed (so get there early) and for good reason; featured guests have been known to include comedy staples of the NY and LA circuits (Louis C.K., Chris RockTodd BarryAziz AnsariDonald Glover) as well as up-and-coming acts and musical sets, such as DJ Roofeeo.

When: Sundays, 9 p.m.
Cost: FREE
WhereThe Knitting Factory, 361 Metropolitan Ave. at Havemeyer St., Williamsburg, Brooklyn

_____________________________

Jared Logan at the inaugural Get It Out There in April at BAM Cafe. Via FB.

GET IT OUT THERE – COMEDY BY BAM & IFC
There are so many great things about this comedy show. It’s hosted in the beautiful BAM café, which, if you haven’t seen it, is gorgeous. The line-up consists of a combination of extremely well-known comics (Wyatt Cenac, Todd Barry) to emerging talent, all of whom use the venue to try out the freshest of their fresh material. Also, there’s a bar and it’s free!

When: Selected Wednesday each month (next one is Sept. 12), Bar Service at 8 p.m., Show at 9 p.m.
Cost: FREE
Where: BAM Café, 30 Lafayette Ave (between Ashland Pl & St Felix St), Fort Greene

_____________________________

THE $10 AND UNDER SHOWS

Avery Monsen, author of All My Friends Are Dead, at The Moon in May.

THE MOON
One of my favorite shows on this planet and elsewhere, The Moon is a comedy/variety show that showcases acts across multiple platforms. Hosted by Nat Towsen and Bob Walles, the show centers around an original theme every month, providing entertainment that runs the gamut from standup comedy, sketch, storytelling, lego animations, dancers, reverse burlesque, music, and videos. Summarized by Moonkid (and friend of Brokelyn) James Beard: “It’s pretty much like The Muppet Show, without the Muppets.”

The Moon consistently books very high caliber guests both big and small – from well-known performers such as Janeane Garofalo, mc chris, and David Cross, to more obscure gems. Reggie Watts is a frequent visitor on The Moon, and if you haven’t yet experienced his crazy improvisational vocal stylings you should make that happen for yourself asap.

When: Every third Tuesday, 8pm (Next show is this Tuesday, Aug. 21)
Cost: $5
Where: Union Pool, 484 Union Ave., Williamsburg

_____________________________

Janeane Garafolo drops by Hot Tub. Photo via Flickr’s mways.

HOT TUB
Hot Tub is Kurt Braunohler’s weekly variety show. From 2005 until this year he ran the show with former co-host Kristen Schaal who just recently left NYC for LA (boo). Braunohler is so funny that he even has a new show on the teevee: Bunk on IFC.

Lucky for us, the live show will go on, and we can continue to expect great comedy, music, and, as their website precises “other weird shit” on a weekly basis. Hot Tub is known for its eclectic musical and comedic guests, such as the Gregory Brothers (of Autotune the News fame), and NYC comedy staples Wyatt Cenac (The Daily Show) and Annie Lederman.

When: Mondays at 8 p.m.
Cost: $5 advance/$8 day of the Show
WhereLittlefield, 622 DeGraw St., Gowanus

_____________________________

 

Sound ceremony in action at Heart Of Darkness. Photo via Joel Barhamand.

HEART OF DARKNESS
Greg Barris is all over the NY comedy scene. So much so that I’ve accidentally seen him three times this summer (he appeared as a guest on some other shows I was at). And you know what? I don’t regret a second of it, because he’s that good. Catch him here at Heart of Darkness on his own turf, and if you’re lucky, maybe you’ll get to hear about that time he went on a date with a dominatrix.

When: Monthly – the last one was this Saturday, Aug. 18
Cost
: $8:
Where: Ongoing monthly residency at Union Hall; will also be at Bell House twice in the next year as well (check website for details)

_____________________________

That time Louis CK came by Party Machine in 2010.

PARTY MACHINE
True to its name, this show really is like being at the super-fun party you wish you were cool enough to throw back in high school. Arden Myrin (MADtv, Chelsea Lately) and Lisa Delarios (Live at Gotham) bring tons of energy and each episode centers on a new theme (examples: Michael Jackson, Prom, Snow day). Adding to the atmosphere is the whimsical 80s/90s throwback dance-music-comedy of Adira Amram and the Experience, winners of the 2011 ECNY Award for Best Musical Act. Not to mention the impressive line ups; past guests have included the likes of Zach Galifianakis, Anna Gasteyer, Michael Showalter, and many many more.

When: Once a month, Saturdays (check the calendar)
Cost: $5
WhereUnion Hall, 702 Union Street, between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, Park Slope

_____________________________

 

Eugene Mirman improves on advertising at Pretty Good Friends. Photo via David Andrako.

PRETTY GOOD FRIENDS
Eugene Mirman’s long-running Sunday show at Union Hall is guaranteed comedy gold. High-quality guests are there every time with varying comedic styles but always the best New York has to offer – these are people who are comfortable with their audience and comfortable with each other, you know, like pretty good friends! Earlier this summer the show moved to the Williamsburg Waterfront for a show with indie band OK Go and Mirman is currently on tour and doing his The Fifth Annual Eugene Mirman Comedy Festival, but check back because this one is definitely worth seeing live.

When: Every Sunday (mostly), doors at 7:30pm. Next one is Sept. 9.
Cost: $7
WhereUnion Hall, 702 Union St., between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, Park Slope

_____________________________

A March flyer for Dead Herring’s comedy show.

DEAD HERRING
One of the cool things about Dead Herring is that it’s basically a loft apartment that doubles as a venue and DIY bar, so there’s that whole intimate, house-party vibe. The guys who run the show are clowns by trade, but the show features a smorgasbord of acts like “magicians, comics, aerial silks and people fisting each other, swear to god.”  These are their own words.

When: Select Saturdays, doors at 8:30, show at 9pm
Cost: $5 Sliding Scale (on one gets turned away if they legitimately can’t afford it)
WhereDead Herring, 141 S 5th St #1E (between Bedford Ave & Driggs Ave), South Williamsburg

_____________________________

Wyatt Cenac at February’s Cheap Date show at Union Hall. Via FB.

CHEAP DATE COMEDY SHOW
Hosted by Sharron Paul (College Humor) & Calvin Cole (TBS Just for Laughs), the show gathers a lot of acts mentioned elsewhere in this post, such as Greg Barris, Wyatt Cenac, and a bunch of great newcomers you may not have heard of. Take the hint and bring your Ok Cupid hookup here, have a laugh, some free snacks (!) and stick around for some bocce ball afterwards.

When: Second Tuesday of every month, 7:30pm
Cost: $5
WhereUnion Hall, 702 Union Street (between 4th and 5th Ave) Park Slope

_____________________________

OUTSIDE BROOKLYN, BUT STILL CHEAP

DADDY’S BASEMENT
This is a show by Skinny Bitch Jesus Meeting (NYC comedy circuit, all sorts of comedy festivals, UCB), which is comprised of the ladies of sketch, the deliciously irreverent duo Katie Hartman and Leah Rudick. Billed as a “Comedy Variety Freakshow Extravaganza,” the show is dark, funny and features sketch, stand-up, music, burlesque and, according to its website “Bare Asses WITHOUT poop on them! (maybe!)”  You can expect high-quality musical guests such as The Reformed Whores and Corn Mo. Worth venturing out of Brooklyn for this one! (The Pit frequently has other free shows on so check out the schedule).

When: 11 p.m., last Friday of every month
Cost: $5
WhereThe PIT, 123 E 24th St (between S Park Ave & Lexington Ave), Flatiron

THE SKINNY WITH PETER DeGIGLIO
This is a different kind of comedy show format, more along the lines of The Daily Show or The Colbert Report. DeGiglio talks about current events, brings on talented performers from all backgrounds, and engages a special guest in an informative yet comedic dialogue. Peter has a weekly “homework” segment where he presents his findings on something he was previously ignorant about. Recently he gave the most concise explanation of the “Higgs-Boson” particle I’ve ever heard, using Gary Coleman as a reference.

When: Second Wednesday of every month
Cost: $10, $8 Students, half-price with the secret password “Year One” (at the door) or “yearone” (on smarttix).
WhereThe Red Room 85 E. 4th St., East Village  

VINTAGE VANTAGE MUSICAL VARIETY SHOW
Kyle Supley’s unique monthly musical-based variety show features “retro miscellany” that harkens back to a simpler time. The show itself is along the lines of old time variety shows such as ‘Sonny and Cher’ and features stand-up comedy and other funny guests, always with the incredible house big band, Pendulum Swings Big Band, providing that extra ambiance.

When: Every fourth Sunday, 9pm
Cost: $8
WhereUnder St. Marks Theater, 94 St. Marks Place, East Village

This is just a sampling of some of the hot talent out there. Let’s hear from you!  What are some of your favorite free/cheap comedy shows in our lovely city?

Related Articles

0

Get a chill with Icelandic films, have an old-school skate-down, rock out for hurricane relief, and more ways to have a splendid week.

0

1. Honor the legacy of urban activist Jane Jacobs by taking a Jane's Walk: there are 200+ on offer, from "Hipsters & History in...

0

It's the first Wednesday of 2016, and it's like every other Wednesday. That's not a bad thing, Wednesday is a herald of the coming...

0

You might have missed it, but it snowed last night, real snow. Of course, it wasn't the kind of snow you could frolic in,...

9 COMMENTS

  1. Jenny Slate also moved to LA, and doesn’t host the big terrific anymore, but it is still going on without her.

  2. I’d appreciate it if you could add “Pant-Hoot,” a free show at Lincoln Park Tavern in PLG that I host on the second Thursday of the month. The next show is on September 13.

    You can see an archive of past shows at http://www.hawthornestreet.com/pant-hoot/

    Pant Hoot Comedy
    Lincoln Park Tavern
    49 Lincoln Road (between Flatbush and Ocean)
    Second Thursday of every month
    FREE
    Hosted by Charles Star who is not famous, even locally

  3. Broken Comedy

    Every Monday night @ 8:30pm @ Bar Matchless 557 Manhattan Ave. Brooklyn, NY. Hosted by Mike Denny, Michael Che, and Nimesh Patel.

  4. There’s also The Fancy Show every Tuesday night at Bar Reis (375 5th Ave at 6th St off the F, G & R trains).

    Veteran comedians curate this Free night of comedy and share the stage with the best talent New York City and the nation has to offer including comics seen on The Tonight Show, Late Night with Seth Myers, SNL, Conan, Chelsea Lately, MTV, Comedy Central and more.

    For line-ups and more information:
    http://facebook.com/thefancyshow
    http://twitter.com/thefancyshow

Leave a Reply