P.J. Hanley’s, Brooklyn’s oldest bar, goes bottoms up

by -
P.J.’s in happier more cash rich times. via Facebook

Brooklyn has a long and proud tradition of alcohol. Either as a haven for brewers or with tons of divey bars, some of whom seem to have existed since before time began. But because time marches on, or people mismanage things, occasionally those bars that have existed forever fall on bad times and face existential threats. In the case of P.J. Hanley’s, it was mismanagement that’s causing the existential threat, which is bankruptcy.

According to Crain’s, the Manhattan-based company that owns P.J.’s filed for Chapter 11, citing a tenant-landlord dispute, rising food costs and incompetent management. They’re looking for a new buyer for the bar, someone who knows how to run one, so it can be taken off their hands. The bar has been in Carroll Gardens since 1874, so it’d be a shame to see it go, for historical reasons. Also because it’s actually a cool bar with a nice outdoor area and tasty jalapeno poppers that someone on staff may or may not have thrown up after one too many spinning rides at Coney Island.

Related Articles


There's no need to be rich as a king to enjoy Brooklyn's unlimited drink brunch specials! Especially not at these 20 restaurants.


Places that will make you seem like a cool kid but also where you can escape quickly if your Tinder date turns out to be a horrible human.


Park Slope's Barbès has long fought the tides of change but, $70,000 in debt, it needs cash fast in order to stick around much longer.


Leave a Reply