A guide to cheap Catskills rentals

by -
5
The living room at Hunter House. $400/night, $1200/wk, $3500/mo

Everyone needs to escape during the summer—relax, get some fresh air and recharge those NYC-grade Energizers we run on the rest of the year. And what’s the perfect place for all this? Why, the Catskill Mountains—near, yet far, the good old Borscht Belt—summer-home to countless New Yorkers for nigh a century. Of course, fresh air can be pricey, even just two and a half hours upstate. So here are some tips on renting and relaxing in the Catskills this summer—and spending as little as if you had stayed in town for the long weekend.

The best sites for scouring cheap rentals are CatskillsByOwner, HomeAway, A House Around the Bend, CyberRentals and VacationRentals. There are two details to keep in mind when calculating the cost: weekend rates and cleaning fees. Weekend stays are usually pricier than going during the week, when you can often get five days for the price of two. And some houses charge a cleaning fee of $75 or more… but that may not be bad thing, depending on how you feel about things like spiders and germs.

Another tip for choosing your rental: look at the pictures. Duh, but a lot of beautiful houses don’t show pictures of the bedrooms. This is especially tricky when it says “1 bedroom, sleeps 6.” Where? Most claim to sleep two more than the bedrooms provide, figuring in a couch or cot. Hardwood floors are good for your back, but maybe not for a whole month.

The best deals are found if you can gather a group of people. There are tons of rentals that sleep up to 10 people. Get a group of people, and you’re looking to each spend about $30 to $50 per night. For a smaller group of four or five, the minimum you’ll pay is $125 nightly ($31/person), and $550 weekly ($137/person). Most are priced at around $700 per week. For a romantic retreat, you and your honey can find one-bedroom cabins at about $100/night, $500/week and $1600/month. Or you could try a B&B, because many of the affordable two-person rentals will bring you back to that summer-camp cabin.

Here are some finds to start your search engines. And, of course, the engine is vast, so we’d love your own tips if you have them.

Great Group Rentals:
Hunter House
– Hunter Mountain. 5 bedrooms, sleeps up to 14. $400/night. $1200/week. $3500/month ($29, $86 and $250 per person—Total!—if 14 go).

Captain’s House -Roxbury. 4 bedrooms, sleeps 10. $1000/2 nights. $1600/3 nights. $2200/6 nights ($100, $160, and $220 per person if 10).

Summer Serenity, Summit Lake. 3 bedrooms, sleeps 12. $350/night (2 night minimum). $1275/week ($30 and $106, if 12).

Phoenicia House Rental, Phoenicia. 6 bedrooms, sleeps 10-12. $1350/week. $4150/month ($112.50 and $345 per person, if 12).

Phoenicia House
This Phoenicia house sleeps 10-12. $1350/wk, $4150/mo

Smaller Groups or Family Rentals:
Greenville Rental House
, Greenville. 2 bedrooms, sleeps 5. $124 – $145/night.  $618 – $876/week.

Catskill Barn, Catskills. 2 bedrooms, sleeps 4. $150/night. $875/week.

Chateau Bond, Windham. 4 bedrooms, sleeps 6. $195/night Fri & Sat. $175/night Sun-Thurs.

Our Romantic Weekend Picks:
Phoenicia House Rental
, Phoenicia. 1 bedroom, sleeps 4. (But, we say really just 2). $525/week

Cozy Phoenicia Rental, Phoenicia. 1 bedroom. $100/night  $600/week, $1,600/month.


Or how about a renovated church?
Or how about a renovated church? $900/wk, $2500/mo

Perfect for Ghost Stories:
Renovated Church
, Worcester. 2 bedrooms, sleeps 6. $900/week. $2500/month. Cleaning fee: $75.

And some Bed and Breakfasts, if you’re interested in having fresh scones:
The Twilight Lodge
Haines Falls, $75 to $125 per night.
Catskill Lodge
Windham, $74.00 to $279.00 per night.
Bed On Clouds B&B Windham. $84.00 to $189.00 per night.

Related Articles

0

As hard as it is to bike up that stupid hill in Prospect Park, it's not quite high enough for great skiing. Places like...

2

Sure, New York's filled with writers and wannabe writers, but with all the noise, nightlife and other distractions (not to mention, that pesky rent...

3

In the market for a new vacation spot now that Fort Tilden's gone this summer? Well, you could spend July sunning yourself outside the...

1

On Upstater, a former Brooklynite who decamped from the Catskills looks back after two years of country living.

5 COMMENTS

  1. YourCountryHomeinGreeneCountyNY.com is a website dedicated to a farmhouse rental in Jewett, NY (5 mins from Windham). The former farm property sits on the banks of the East Kill Creek, a locally stocked trout stream which has many swimming holes. One can rent for 2 day, weekly or monthly rentals. Please visit our website and book now for summer stays!

  2. Catskills are too far for us.  Our family summers in N Westchester at a lakeside bungalow colony.  Under an hour by train from Grand Central or about an hour from Brooklyn (depending on traffic, of course).  It’s got all the old school features – tennis, basketball, swimming, entertainment in the Social Hall. And it’s affordable – http://pinelakeparkcoop.blogspot.com/

Leave a Reply